The Ballon d’Or – a name that echoes with prestige and history in the world of football. For decades, this gleaming golden sphere has symbolised individual excellence, recognising the planet’s most outstanding footballer. It’s more than just a trophy; it’s a testament to a player’s unparalleled skill, dedication, and impact on the beautiful game over a given season. From its humble beginnings as a European award to its current global stature, the Ballon d’Or has captivated fans, sparked endless debates, and inspired generations of aspiring footballers.
A Rich History: From European Honour to Global Icon
The story of the Ballon d’Or began in 1956, conceived by France Football magazine’s chief magazine writer, Gabriel Hanot. Initially known as the “European Footballer of the Year” award, it was strictly for European players plying their trade in European leagues. The inaugural winner was the legendary Stanley Matthews of England, a testament to his enduring talent even in his advanced years.
The award’s criteria evolved. In 1995, a significant change broadened its scope to include players of any nationality, provided they were playing for European clubs. This pivotal shift saw Liberian George Weah become the first non-European recipient, marking a new era of inclusivity. The final expansion came in 2007, making all professional footballers from clubs worldwide eligible, truly transforming it into a global prize.
Between 2010 and 2015, the Ballon d’Or merged with FIFA’s “World Player of the Year” award, creating the FIFA Ballon d’Or. This collaboration aimed to unify the two most prestigious individual honours in football. However, the partnership concluded after six editions, with France Football resuming independent control of the Ballon d’Or, and FIFA re-establishing its own “The Best FIFA Men’s Player” award.
Throughout its history, the Ballon d’Or has celebrated iconic figures. Legends like Alfredo Di Stéfano, Johan Cruyff, Michel Platini, and Marco van Basten each claimed the coveted prize multiple times, cementing their places in footballing folklore. These early winners laid the groundwork for the award’s unparalleled status, showcasing the incredible talent that graced pitches across Europe.
The Era of Dominance: Messi and Ronaldo
The 21st century witnessed an unprecedented duopoly dominate the Ballon d’Or landscape: Lionel Messi and Cristiano Ronaldo. Their rivalry, spanning over a decade, became synonymous with the award itself. These two titans of the game pushed each other to extraordinary heights, redefining what was thought possible in modern football.
Lionel Messi currently holds the record for the most Ballon d’Or wins, with a remarkable eight titles. His sublime dribbling, exquisite vision, and prolific goalscoring have consistently set him apart. Cristiano Ronaldo, with five Ballon d’Or trophies, trails closely behind. His relentless drive, incredible athleticism, and clinical finishing have made him one of the most feared attackers in the sport’s history.
Their dominance was so absolute that between 2008 and 2023, only Luka Modric (2018) and Karim Benzema (2022) managed to break their stranglehold on the award. This era sparked countless debates among fans and pundits about who was the “greatest of all time,” with the Ballon d’Or often serving as a key metric in these discussions. The sheer volume of individual accolades amassed by Messi and Ronaldo highlighted their consistent excellence at the very highest level of the game. Their rivalry transcended club loyalties, becoming a global phenomenon that brought unprecedented attention to the Ballon d’Or ceremony each year.
The Voting Process: A Look Behind the Golden Curtain
The Ballon d’Or is not simply handed out; it’s the result of a meticulously structured voting process. Since 2022, the award has recognised player performance during the previous season (August to July) rather than the calendar year, providing a more coherent evaluation aligned with the typical football season.
The award’s criteria are based on three main pillars:
Individual performances, decisive and impressive character
This criterion assesses a player’s direct impact on matches, their leadership qualities, and their ability to produce game-changing moments.
Team performances and achievements
While an individual award, the success of a player’s team is inherently linked to their overall contribution. Trophies won and significant team achievements play a crucial role.
Class and fair play
This element considers a player’s conduct on and off the pitch, promoting sportsmanship and respect for the game.
The jury primarily comprises specialised journalists, with one representative per country from the top 100 in the latest FIFA rankings. Each juror selects their top ten players from a 30-man shortlist compiled by the editorial staff of France Football, members of the editorial staff of L’Équipe, the best juror from the previous edition, and UEFA ambassadors. Points are then allocated in descending order: 15 for the first choice, 12 for the second, 10 for the third, and so on, down to 1 point for the tenth choice. The player with the highest total points wins the Ballon d’Or. In case of a tie, the number of first-place votes determines the winner.
The transparency of this process, though sometimes criticised, aims to ensure a fair and objective assessment of a player’s season. The diverse panel of journalists offers a broad perspective, theoretically mitigating national or club biases.
Recent Trends and the Shifting Landscape
The 2024 Ballon d’Or ceremony marked a significant departure from the Messi-Ronaldo era, with Rodri of Manchester City becoming the first midfielder since Luka Modric in 2018 to claim the award. This signals a potential shift in the criteria or voter perception, moving away from the absolute dominance of prolific forwards.
Rodri’s victory was a recognition of his instrumental role in Manchester City’s treble-winning season, which included the Premier League, FA Cup, and Champions League. His consistent excellence in midfield, his ability to dictate play, and his crucial goals in big moments were undoubtedly key factors. Other strong contenders for the 2024 award included Real Madrid’s Vinícius Júnior and Jude Bellingham, both of whom had sensational seasons for their respective clubs. Vinícius Júnior’s explosive attacking talent and Champions League heroics, coupled with Bellingham’s immediate impact at Real Madrid and prolific goalscoring from midfield, made them formidable rivals.
This diversification of winners and the emergence of new, compelling narratives suggest a more open race for the Ballon d’Or in the coming years. While individual brilliance remains paramount, the importance of team success and a player’s all-round contribution across various competitions seems to be gaining increased recognition. The absence of Messi and Ronaldo from the 2024 shortlist for the first time in a long while truly signifies the beginning of a new chapter for the prestigious award.
The Debate and Criticism: A Golden Ball Under Scrutiny
Despite its revered status, the Ballon d’Or has never been immune to criticism and debate. In fact, these discussions are often as fervent as the award ceremony itself. One recurring point of contention is the perceived bias towards attacking players. Historically, forwards and attacking midfielders have dominated the awards, leading to questions about whether the contributions of defenders and goalkeepers are adequately recognised. While defenders like Fabio Cannavaro (2006) and goalkeepers like Lev Yashin (1963) have won, they remain rare exceptions.
Another significant area of debate revolves around the weight given to individual brilliance versus team trophies. Some argue that a player’s individual statistics and performances should be the sole determinant, regardless of their team’s silverware. Others contend that a player’s ability to elevate their team to collective glory is a crucial indicator of their overall impact. The 2010 award, where Lionel Messi won despite Wesley Sneijder’s treble with Inter Milan and World Cup final appearance, is often cited as a prime example of this debate. Similarly, the 2023 award for Messi, heavily influenced by Argentina’s World Cup triumph, sparked considerable discussion, with many arguing that Erling Haaland, with his prolific goalscoring and club treble, was more deserving based on the full season’s club performance.
The impact of “narrative” and “marketability” also frequently comes under scrutiny. Critics suggest that popular storylines, media narratives, and a player’s global brand can sometimes influence voting outcomes, potentially overshadowing objectively superior performances. The recent 2024 ceremony saw heated discussions, particularly concerning Rodri’s win over Vinícius Júnior, with some prominent figures, including Cristiano Ronaldo, publicly voicing their disagreement. Real Madrid’s boycott of the 2024 ceremony, reportedly in protest of Vinícius Júnior not winning, further highlighted the passion and contention surrounding the award. These controversies, while fuelling fan engagement, also raise important questions about the award’s impartiality and selection criteria.
The shift to evaluating performance over a season rather than a calendar year was an attempt to address some of these concerns, providing a clearer and more cohesive basis for judgment. However, the subjective nature of judging “the best” player in a team sport ensures that the debates around the Ballon d’Or will likely continue for as long as the award exists.
The Ballon d’Or’s Impact on the Beautiful Game
Beyond the individual recognition, the Ballon d’Or wields significant influence on the world of football. For players, winning the award is the pinnacle of individual achievement. It represents the culmination of years of hard work, sacrifice, and relentless pursuit of excellence. The desire to lift the golden ball fuels players to push their limits, inspiring them to consistently perform at the highest level. The increased global exposure and commercial opportunities that come with winning the Ballon d’Or can be transformative for a player’s career.
For clubs, having a Ballon d’Or winner in their ranks is a source of immense pride and a powerful marketing tool. It elevates the club’s profile, attracts top talent, and boosts commercial revenue. Clubs like Real Madrid and Barcelona, who have historically produced numerous winners, often leverage this prestige to reinforce their status as footballing powerhouses. The award also influences transfer market dynamics, with Ballon d’Or contenders often commanding higher transfer fees and wages.
On a broader scale, the Ballon d’Or contributes to the ongoing narrative and discourse around football. It provides a focal point for discussions about player performance, tactical innovations, and the evolution of the game. The anticipation leading up to the ceremony, the unveiling of the nominees, and the eventual winner announcement generate significant media attention and fan engagement worldwide. It keeps the spotlight on individual brilliance within a team sport, adding another layer of intrigue and excitement to the football calendar. The award, therefore, isn’t just a celebration; it’s a driving force that continues to shape the sport’s competitive and commercial landscape.
The Future of the Golden Ball
As football continues to evolve, so too will the Ballon d’Or. The recent shift to a season-based evaluation and the increasing number of strong contenders outside the traditional duopoly hint at a more diverse future for the award. The next generation of superstars, such as Jude Bellingham, Kylian Mbappé, and Vinícius Júnior, are already making their mark and are widely tipped to dominate future editions.
The debate around the award’s criteria will undoubtedly persist, with ongoing discussions about the weighting of individual statistics versus team success, and the representation of different playing positions. The increasing global reach of football and the emergence of talent from non-traditional footballing nations might also lead to a more geographically diverse pool of nominees and winners in the years to come.
Furthermore, the integration of advanced analytics and data-driven insights in football is becoming more prevalent. While the Ballon d’Or’s voting remains largely based on journalistic opinion, there could be a growing call for incorporating more objective metrics to complement the subjective assessments. The collaboration between France Football and UEFA, as seen in the co-organisation of the 2024 awards, also suggests a potential for further partnerships and refinements to the award’s structure and reach.
Ultimately, the Ballon d’Or’s enduring legacy lies in its ability to spark conversation, inspire dreams, and celebrate the extraordinary individuals who elevate football to an art form. Its future will likely see it continue to adapt, reflecting the ever-changing dynamics of the world’s most popular sport.
FAQs
How many Ballon d’Or awards does Lionel Messi have?
Lionel Messi holds the record for the most Ballon d’Or wins, with a remarkable eight titles.
How many Ballon d’Or awards does Cristiano Ronaldo have?
Cristiano Ronaldo has won the Ballon d’Or five times.
Who won the Ballon d’Or in 2024?
Rodri, the Spanish midfielder for Manchester City, won the Ballon d’Or in 2024.
What are the main criteria for winning the Ballon d’Or?
The main criteria are individual performances and character, team performances and achievements, and class and fair play.
Has a defender ever won the Ballon d’Or?
Yes, a defender has won the Ballon d’Or. Fabio Cannavaro won the award in 2006.
Final Thought
The Ballon d’Or stands as a powerful symbol in football, transcending mere silverware to represent the pinnacle of individual achievement. From its origins as a European accolade to its current global resonance, it has consistently adapted, albeit sometimes controversially, to reflect the evolving landscape of the beautiful game. While the era of Messi and Ronaldo’s unprecedented dominance may be drawing to a close, the award continues to ignite passionate debate, drive players to extraordinary heights, and captivate audiences worldwide. As new generations of talent emerge and the sport itself transforms, the golden ball will undoubtedly remain a coveted prize, a beacon of individual excellence in a team-centric sport. Its continued relevance lies in its ability to recognise and celebrate the very best, ensuring its place in footballing history for many years to come.
To read more, Click here