This phenomenon is Bad Sisters, an Irish black comedy television series developed by Sharon Horgan, Dave Finkel, and Brett Baer. Bursting onto the scene in 2022, and continuing its compelling narrative with a second season in late 2024, the show has garnered widespread critical acclaim and captivated global audiences on Apple TV.
Its genius lies in its audacious premise: a group of sisters, bound by an unshakeable familial loyalty, conspire to dispatch their sister’s abusive husband, a man so vile he is colloquially known as “The Prick.”
The Genesis of a Ghoulishly Good Comedy: Sharon Horgan’s Vision
At the heart of “Bad Sisters” lies the distinctive voice and creative prowess of Sharon Horgan. An accomplished Irish actress, writer, and producer, Horgan has consistently pushed boundaries in comedy and drama, often exploring the messy, complicated realities of modern relationships and family life.
Her previous works, such as “Catastrophe” (co-written with Rob Delaney) and “Motherland,” are celebrated for their witty dialogue, relatable characters, and unflinching honesty. These shows established Horgan’s signature style: a blend of biting humor, genuine emotional depth, and a knack for finding comedy in dark situations.
The Collaborative Genius: Dave Finkel and Brett Baer
While Sharon Horgan is undeniably the driving force, the development of “Bad Sisters” as an Irish black comedy series was a collaborative effort with American writers and producers Dave Finkel and Brett Baer. Their combined expertise, particularly in the realm of American sitcoms and comedic writing, brought a unique dynamic to the series’ development.
Finkel and Baer’s backgrounds include extensive work on successful comedies such as “30 Rock” and “New Girl.” Their experience in crafting sharp, fast-paced dialogue and intricate plotlines, often involving ensemble casts, was invaluable.
In “Bad Sisters,” their contributions likely helped to refine the comedic timing, structure the dual timelines (past murder attempts and present-day investigation), and ensure the plot maintained its suspenseful momentum while delivering consistent laughs.
The collaboration between an Irish comedic voice (Horgan) and American writing sensibilities (Finkel and Baer) created a show that feels both distinctly Irish in its setting and humor, yet universally appealing in its themes of family, loyalty, and justice. This transatlantic partnership ensured that the humor translated across cultures while retaining its authentic roots. As executive producers alongside Horgan, their oversight of the series’ creative direction was fundamental to its cohesive and compelling narrative.
Deconstructing the Black Comedy Genre in “Bad Sisters”
“Bad Sisters” is a quintessential example of black comedy, also known as dark humor or gallows humor. This genre is characterized by its humorous treatment of serious, disturbing, or morbid subjects, such as death, disease, violence, and abuse. The humor often arises from irony, cynicism, and the subversion of expectations.
Key Elements of Black Comedy in “Bad Sisters”:
Taboo Subjects: The core premise revolves around a murder plot, a gravely serious act. The show lightens this by showcasing the sisters’ often incompetent and absurd attempts, making the act of murder itself a source of dark amusement rather than pure horror.
Moral Ambiguity: While John Paul is clearly a villain, the sisters are still plotting murder. The show expertly plays with the audience’s moral compass, encouraging them to root for the “bad sisters” because their victim is worse. This ambiguity is a hallmark of effective black comedy.
Satire and Social Commentary: “Bad Sisters” subtly satirizes patriarchal structures, the societal pressures on women, and the insidious nature of domestic abuse. John Paul embodies a toxic masculinity that is not just annoying but actively destructive. The humor often serves to highlight the absurdity and injustice of his actions.
Unexpected Juxtaposition: The show frequently juxtaposes moments of intense drama or emotional vulnerability with sudden bursts of slapstick or witty banter. This tonal shift keeps the audience on their toes and enhances the comedic impact. For example, a tense scene discussing a murder method might be immediately followed by a sister making a dry, hilarious comment.
Coping Mechanism: For the Garvey sisters, and indeed for the audience, humor acts as a coping mechanism. Faced with an unbearable situation, the sisters resort to outlandish schemes, and their shared plight fosters a dark camaraderie that provides comic relief amidst the tension.
Production Excellence: Bringing Dublin to Life
“Bad Sisters” benefits immensely from its high production values, especially its authentic Irish setting. Filmed on location in Dublin and County Wicklow, the series beautifully captures the rugged beauty of the Irish coast, particularly the iconic Forty Foot bathing area, which serves as a recurring meeting point for the sisters.
Step-by-Step Production Insights:
Adaptation & Development: The process began with acquiring the rights to “Clan.” Sharon Horgan, Dave Finkel, and Brett Baer then embarked on a meticulous development phase, adapting the Belgian story to an Irish context. This involved creating new character backstories, refining dialogue to reflect Irish sensibilities, and mapping out the dual timeline narrative.
Casting: A significant effort was put into casting the five Garvey sisters, ensuring strong chemistry and individual depth. The casting of Claes Bang as John Paul was equally crucial, as his ability to embody such a detestable character was paramount to the show’s success. The series boasts a wealth of talent from Irish television and film, contributing to its authentic feel.
Location Scouting: The choice of Dublin and Wicklow as primary filming locations was deliberate. These locations not only provide stunning visuals but also contribute to the series’ unique atmosphere, grounding the dark humor in a tangible, picturesque reality. The Forty Foot, a real-life swimming spot, becomes almost a character in itself, symbolizing the sisters’ shared history and sanctuary.
Writing & Directing: The writing team, led by Horgan, crafted scripts that seamlessly weave between past and present, balancing comedic beats with moments of genuine tension and emotional resonance. Directors like Dearbhla Walsh (“The Handmaid’s Tale,” “Fargo”) brought a keen eye for visual storytelling and character performance, ensuring the show’s distinctive tone was consistently maintained.
Music & Cinematography: The series’ score, particularly the opening theme, adds a layer of dark whimsy, enhancing the black comedy elements. The cinematography captures the beauty of the Irish landscape while also effectively framing the intimate, often intense, interactions between the characters.
Practical Tips and How-Tos
For aspiring screenwriters, producers, or anyone interested in creative storytelling, “Bad Sisters” offers valuable insights:
How to Craft a Compelling Dark Comedy:
Establish a Clear Moral Dilemma: The core of “Bad Sisters” is the moral ambiguity of plotting murder. Make your audience question, but also understand, your characters’ choices.
Make Your Villain Truly Despicable: For audiences to accept dark deeds from protagonists, the antagonist must be profoundly awful. John Paul’s relentless, petty cruelty makes him a perfect target.
Ground the Story in Relatable Emotion: Despite the outlandish plot, the show is rooted in universal themes: sisterhood, loyalty, grief, and the desire for justice. Emotional authenticity makes the dark humor more impactful.
Master the Dual Timeline: If using a non-linear narrative, ensure both timelines are equally engaging and serve to enhance the overall mystery and character development. “Bad Sisters” uses the past to show the mounting frustration and the present to drive the investigation.
Inject Humor Through Character and Situation: Don’t force jokes. Let the humor arise organically from the characters’ personalities, their interactions, and the absurd situations they find themselves in. The sisters’ bickering and ineptitude are prime sources of comedy.
Embrace Subtlety: While the premise is bold, much of the humor and character work in “Bad Sisters” is subtle. It trusts the audience to pick up on nuances and implied meanings.
How to Build Strong Ensemble Chemistry:
Develop Distinctive Personalities: Each Garvey sister has a unique personality, set of struggles, and comedic quirks. This prevents them from blending together.
Focus on Shared History and Bonds: The show continually emphasizes the sisters’ deep, long-standing connection, which makes their loyalty believable and their collective actions understandable.
Allow for Conflict and Resolution: Even within a strong bond, siblings argue. “Bad Sisters” shows both the loving and contentious aspects of sisterhood, making their relationships feel real.
Prioritize Rehearsal and Collaborative Work: The naturalistic chemistry among the cast is a result of effective direction and the actors’ collaborative efforts, allowing them to truly embody their familial relationships.
FAQ
What is “black comedy” and how does “Bad Sisters” exemplify it?
Black comedy (or dark humor) is a genre that finds humor in subjects typically considered taboo, morbid, or serious, such as death, abuse, or misfortune. “Bad Sisters” exemplifies this by centering its plot around the murder of an abusive husband. The humor arises from the sisters’ bumbling attempts to carry out the deed, their relatable bickering, and the stark contrast between the grim premise and the witty dialogue, making the audience root for their morally ambiguous actions against an undeniably terrible man.
Is “Bad Sisters” based on a true story?
No, “Bad Sisters” is not based on a true story. It is an adaptation of the Flemish television series “Clan,” which was created by Malin-Sarah Gozin. Sharon Horgan, Dave Finkel, and Brett Baer developed the Irish adaptation, bringing their unique creative vision and an authentic Irish cultural context to the original concept.
How does the dual timeline structure enhance the viewing experience in “Bad Sisters”?
The dual timeline structure, alternating between the sisters’ past attempts to kill John Paul and the present-day investigation into his death, significantly enhances the viewing experience. It creates suspense by gradually revealing the circumstances of John Paul’s demise, while also providing comedic relief through the escalating absurdity of their past murder plots. This narrative technique keeps the audience engaged, allowing for both a gripping mystery and a detailed character study of the sisters’ motivations and dynamics.
What is the significance of the “Forty Foot” in “Bad Sisters”?
The “Forty Foot” is a real-life, iconic open-sea swimming spot in Dublin, Ireland. In “Bad Sisters,” it serves as a symbolic meeting place for the Garvey sisters. It represents their shared history, their enduring bond, and a sanctuary where they can be vulnerable and honest with each other, often discussing their dark plans against John Paul. It visually grounds their fantastical schemes in a tangible, beloved Irish landmark, adding to the show’s authentic sense of place.
Final Thoughts
Bad Sisters, developed by the formidable trio of Sharon Horgan, Dave Finkel, and Brett Baer, stands as a crowning achievement in contemporary Irish black comedy. It is a testament to the power of a compelling narrative, sharp writing, and exceptional performances.
The series not only entertains with its gripping mystery and laugh-out-loud moments but also provokes thought on themes of familial loyalty, the insidious nature of abuse, and the pursuit of justice. Its critical acclaim, consistent viewership, and numerous awards underscore its impact and broad appeal.
As television continues to evolve, “Bad Sisters” serves as a benchmark for how to successfully blend genres, create unforgettable characters, and tell stories that resonate deeply with audiences across the globe.
It is a shining example of how a distinctly local story, told with universal themes and an unflinching comedic lens, can achieve international success, proving that sometimes, the most twisted situations yield the most heartwarming (and hilarious) portrayals of sisterhood. The show’s continued success into its second season in 2024 further solidifies its status as a modern classic, ensuring its place in the pantheon of great dark comedies.
To read more, Click here