The name Todd Hodne evokes a chilling chapter in criminal history, closely intertwined with the seemingly idyllic world of collegiate sports and the dark underbelly of unchecked violence. 

This article delves into the complex and disturbing narrative surrounding Todd Steven Hodne, a former Penn State football player whose life spiraled into a series of horrific crimes, leaving a profound impact on his victims and raising critical questions about institutional accountability and the justice system. 

We will explore his background, the details of his crimes, the legal proceedings that followed, and the enduring legacy of his actions, offering a comprehensive overview for those seeking to understand this deeply unsettling case.

Who Was Todd Hodne? A Troubled Beginning

Todd Steven Hodne was born on April 23, 1959. He gained notoriety as a promising young athlete from Wantagh, Long Island, New York, attending St. Dominic High School before being recruited to play linebacker for the prestigious Penn State University football team. 

In 1977, as a freshman, he played in at least seven games, including the Fiesta Bowl. However, his athletic promise was tragically overshadowed by a disturbing pattern of criminal behavior that began long before his most heinous acts.

His early brushes with the law included a burglary charge in the summer before his sophomore year at Penn State, which led to his suspension from the team. Despite coach Joe Paterno’s statement that Hodne could return if he had a good academic year and proved himself, this incident was a harbinger of the escalating violence to come.

The Crimes of Todd Hodne: A Reign of Terror

The true horror of Todd Hodne’s actions emerged through a series of sexual assaults, first at Penn State and then in his hometown. These crimes were characterized by their brutality and the psychological trauma inflicted upon his victims.

The Penn State Assaults

While a student at Penn State, Hodne sexually assaulted at least two university students in 1978. One of the most prominent victims, Betsy Sailor, a 21-year-old senior, was raped at knifepoint in her off-campus apartment. Her brave testimony in court was crucial in bringing Hodne to justice for this crime. These assaults cast a long shadow over the university, raising questions about how such a dangerous individual could operate within a prominent institution.

The Murder of a Taxi Driver

Even after serving time for his sexual assault convictions, Hodne’s criminal trajectory continued its grim path. In 1986, despite objections from the Nassau County prosecutor who detailed his continued danger to society, Hodne was granted parole. This decision would prove to have fatal consequences.

On August 11, 1987, just a year after his release, Todd Hodne murdered a taxi driver, Emanuel Hirsch, during a robbery in Huntington, New York. He attempted to rob Hirsch with a knife and then strangled him. He was eventually convicted of murder and sentenced to 25 years to life in prison, where he spent the remainder of his life.

The Legal Journey: Trials, Convictions, and Controversies

The legal proceedings surrounding Todd Hodne were complex and fraught with controversy, highlighting systemic issues within the justice and correctional systems.

Initial Convictions and Sentencing

In the Penn State case, Hodne was found guilty of criminal sexual assault after Betsy Sailor’s testimony. He was expelled from the university in December 1978. However, instead of being remanded into custody, he was granted bail and returned home, a decision that allowed him to continue his crime spree.

In September 1979, six months after his Penn State conviction, Hodne entered a plea agreement in Nassau County, pleading guilty to two counts of rape, two counts of sexual abuse, and one count of attempted second-degree robbery. 

He was sentenced to a minimum of seven years and a maximum of twenty-one years, to be served consecutively with his Pennsylvania conviction. This meant he served a total of seven years for these collective crimes.

Murder Conviction and Life Imprisonment

His murder conviction for the death of Emanuel Hirsch in 1987 sealed his fate, leading to a sentence of 25 years to life. This marked the end of his active criminal career, as he remained incarcerated until his death. At his sole parole hearing for the murder conviction, he recanted his initial self-defense claim.

The Enduring Impact: Victims, Institutions, and Society

The impact of Todd Hodne’s crimes extends far beyond the individual acts, resonating with his victims, challenging institutions, and shaping public discourse on issues of sexual violence, accountability, and the justice system.

Institutional Accountability: Penn State and Beyond

The connection of Hodne’s crimes to Penn State University, particularly in the wake of the Jerry Sandusky scandal, has reignited discussions about institutional responsibility in addressing and preventing sexual assault. 

The case serves as a powerful reminder of the need for robust reporting mechanisms, swift and appropriate disciplinary actions, and comprehensive support systems for victims within educational institutions.

Lessons for the Justice System

Hodne’s parole in 1986, which directly preceded his murder of a taxi driver, is a critical case study in parole board decision-making. It underscores the immense responsibility of parole boards to balance rehabilitation with public safety, and the potential catastrophic consequences of misjudging an offender’s risk. 

This case, among others, has likely contributed to ongoing debates and reforms aimed at improving risk assessment tools and ensuring greater accountability within parole systems.

FAQ

Who was Todd Hodne and what is he primarily known for?

Todd Hodne was a former Penn State University football player who gained notoriety for a series of sexual assaults he committed in the late 1970s, both while attending Penn State and subsequently in his hometown of Wantagh, New York. He is also known for murdering a taxi driver in 1987 while on parole for his earlier crimes, for which he spent the remainder of his life in prison.

When did Todd Hodne’s crimes occur, and when did he die?

Todd Hodne’s sexual assault spree began in 1978 and continued into 1979. He murdered a taxi driver in 1987. Todd Hodne died on April 29, 2020, from cancer, while incarcerated.

What role did Penn State University play in the Todd Hodne case?

Todd Hodne was a Penn State football player when he committed some of his initial sexual assaults. The university expelled him after his conviction for one of these assaults. The case, particularly when revisited in 2022, raised questions about the university’s handling of the allegations at the time and its responsibility in addressing such conduct within its athletic program.

What is the significance of the ESPN.com article “Untold” regarding Todd Hodne?

The 2022 ESPN.com article “Untold” by Tom Junod and Paula Lavigne brought renewed national attention to Todd Hodne’s crimes. Crucially, it provided a platform for his survivors to share their stories publicly, many for the first time, decades after the assaults. The article highlighted the devastating impact of his actions and raised critical questions about institutional accountability and the justice system’s handling of his case.

Final Thoughts

The story of Todd Hodne is a stark and painful reminder of the devastating consequences of unchecked violence and the systemic failures that can allow such individuals to re-offend. It is a narrative that speaks to the enduring trauma experienced by survivors, the complex ethical dilemmas faced by institutions, and the persistent challenges within the criminal justice system, particularly concerning parole and risk assessment.

While Hodne’s life ended in 2020, the echoes of his crimes continue to resonate. The renewed attention to his case, spurred by diligent investigative journalism, underscores a societal shift towards greater accountability, victim empowerment, and a more critical examination of institutional responses to sexual violence. 

As of 2025, the ongoing commitment to supporting survivors, refining legal processes, and fostering cultures of safety and respect serves as a powerful testament to the lessons, however grim, that cases like Todd Hodne’s continue to teach us. The collective hope remains that by understanding and confronting these dark chapters, we can work towards a future where such tragedies are prevented, and justice, in its fullest sense, is truly served.

To read more, Click here